Armchair Dragoons Forums
Wargaming => The Modern World => Topic started by: judgedredd on May 30, 2020, 06:55:17 PM
-
So I may have posted before about this...but it's still a subject matter that seems to evade me.
Apologies if I'm repeating myself...
I have LnL Tactical Heroes of the Nam. Good game
and I enjoy it.
But still, I feel I'm missing something in the Vietnam/Korean era.
I have Silver Bayonet 25th anniversary edition...but doesn't look like the scale I'm looking for. I haven't played it, I've clipped all the counters and I took photos today to sell it because...mainly, the scale doesn't suit me. But I've not put it up for sale yet...the quality of the game looks great.
Basically, I want to fight Ia Drang in platoon or squad level. That's really the scale and the specific action I'm looking for...
Failing that, a nice Korean company/platoon level game would be nice
I may have tired some of you out...but if you have any suggestions, of appreciate it
-
'65 Nam, maybe
I think there's a Squad Leader Korea game, no?
-
Fields of Fire by GMT?
-
Fields of Fire by GMT?
agreed for solo ... korea platoon ... take a look at Platoon Commander Korea by tinybattles
https://tinybattlepublishing.com/products/platoon-commander-korea-1950
I saw this from white dog ... I think it is solo ... (not Ia Drang ... and goes back to before the french left the fight)
http://www.whitedoggames.com/dienbienphu
-
I think there's a Squad Leader Korea game, no?
Yes, there is (Forgotten War), but it's at the squad level. And Mr. Dredd has said before that he didn't really like ASL.
-
Avalanche Press has a Korean tactical level game in the Panzer Grenadier line. http://www.avalanchepress.com/gameCounterAttack.php (http://www.avalanchepress.com/gameCounterAttack.php)
-
there are the games from HFD (high flying dice) ... maybe still too high? (I believe the counters are companies and battalions)
http://www.hfdgames.com/cold.html (http://www.hfdgames.com/cold.html)
-
'65 Nam, maybe
Aye - I was eyeing that one :bigthumb:
-
I think there's a Squad Leader Korea game, no?
Yes, there is (Forgotten War), but it's at the squad level. And Mr. Dredd has said before that he didn't really like ASL.
Well...ASL certainly wasn't for me - but as for squad level, I think at the time I was looking for a single man chit game. I'm well aware (after looking for a long time) that most games are not single man.
I've accepted that I need to look above that scale and into squad/platoon and even, depending on the scale of the conflict, company in some cases. But I don't want to go to strategic level - like Hearts and Minds.
As I say - I've got Silver Bayonet and was about to sell it because the Ia Drang fight in it is not at all the scale I'm looking for (iirc the US has 3 chits - so it's at company level).
-
Fields of Fire by GMT?
I did consider FoF - but I've read a fair few people mentioning a good system ruined by vague rules. Also, I'm not a massive fan of the that "kind" of game. I even sold my Warfighter game. I like chits/counters and maps - not cards making up terrain (though I see huge playability in those kinds of games).
-
Fields of Fire by GMT?
agreed for solo ... korea platoon ... take a look at Platoon Commander Korea by tinybattles
https://tinybattlepublishing.com/products/platoon-commander-korea-1950
I saw this from white dog ... I think it is solo ... (not Ia Drang ... and goes back to before the french left the fight)
http://www.whitedoggames.com/dienbienphu
No and no - but thank you for the suggestions.
-
I think I may be being too specific. Most games seem to be strategic - but of course that isn't my only "want"...I want chits, nice maps, good looking, informative chits, easy manual and game system.
I think I'll give Silver Bayonet a go before I pass it on...so I'm making an informed decision. It is a cracking looking game and has a great mounted map. I at least owe it to get it to the table.
Also - maybe I should bite the bullet and consider something of the strategic nature covering the whole war like Fire in the Lake or Hearts and Minds...broaden my horizons a bit.
Thank you.
-
There's also this one. I think we've talked about it before
https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/229351/it-started-here
-
Victory Games did a Korean War game that was really good - not sure, but I think the one done by Compass is a remake.
-
Victory Games did a Korean War game that was really good - not sure, but I think the one done by Compass is a remake.
Compass has "Yalu!". I have a copy that has the new version and the original rules. Nice game, but definitely not squad level. I'm not sure how interesting squad/platoon level would be for either conflict. For an Ia Drang focus, Silver Bayonet is the way to go.
-
NO, you're right - I did not read JD's post properly - The Victory Game's game and the new one by Compass are Operational level.
-
Victory Games did a Korean War game that was really good - not sure, but I think the one done by Compass is a remake.
Compass has "Yalu!". I have a copy that has the new version and the original rules. Nice game, but definitely not squad level. I'm not sure how interesting squad/platoon level would be for either conflict. For an Ia Drang focus, Silver Bayonet is the way to go.
Yeah - but it's company level and there just doesn't seem a lot to do and no room for tactical maneuver. I kind of wanted the scale where I could employ some tactics.
So actually rather than looking for a Vietnam game per se - I'm looking for an Ia Drang game.
There's also this one. I think we've talked about it before
https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/229351/it-started-here
Thanks but I can't see that for sale outside the US. I know there's print and play - but I didn't really want P+P
-
How about Front Towards Enemy from MMP?
http://www.multimanpublishing.com/tabid/58/CategoryID/2/ProductID/318/Default.aspx
-
How about Front Towards Enemy from MMP?
http://www.multimanpublishing.com/tabid/58/CategoryID/2/ProductID/318/Default.aspx (http://www.multimanpublishing.com/tabid/58/CategoryID/2/ProductID/318/Default.aspx)
Nice. I might need that one.
-
Do it!
-
you first!
-
Mike's got 'Great War Commander' on his list first :whistle:
-
How about Front Towards Enemy from MMP?
http://www.multimanpublishing.com/tabid/58/CategoryID/2/ProductID/318/Default.aspx
Excellent. Bought and thank you :bigthumb:
-
Mike's got 'Great War Commander' on his list first :whistle:
He doesn't need to play games. He just needs to buy them.
-
That reminds me. I need to sticker Fields of Despair.
-
Stickers?
...as in......blocks?
<shudder>
It'll be meeples next, laddie...........
-
And then... meeples with stickers...
-
Shock Horror!
Go and scrub your keyboard with disinfectant immediately.
-
The block mechanic works nicely in FoD. I do hate stickering the blocks though.
-
Being honest, I've never actually ever played any block games, so I'm just engaging in a bit of the old wind-up :-)
-
Being honest, I've never actually ever played any block games, so I'm just engaging in a bit of the old wind-up :-)
You and the old wind
-
Blocks are the gateway to meeples and cubes. Fact.
-
The block mechanic works nicely in FoD. I do hate stickering the blocks though.
Isn't that what the kids are for?