Armchair Dragoons Forums
Wargaming => Professional Wargaming => Topic started by: bayonetbrant on December 17, 2019, 07:56:36 PM
-
https://www.3rdmardiv.marines.mil/News/News-Article-Display/Article/2040459/3rd-marine-division-challenges-junior-marines-with-war-games/ (https://www.3rdmardiv.marines.mil/News/News-Article-Display/Article/2040459/3rd-marine-division-challenges-junior-marines-with-war-games/)
CAMP SCHWAB, Okinawa, Japan -- U.S. Marines with 4th Marine Regiment, 3rd Marine Division, participated in a tournament style board game, Memoir 44’, to analyze individual Marines’ strategic decision making skills on Camp Schwab, Okinawa, Japan, Dec. 10, 2019.
Memoir 44’ is a war-themed strategy board game based on historical World War II battles. The primary goal of using board games is to keep Marines engaged in strategic decision making and risk management in a forgiving environment.
“Memoir 44 is something off the shelf that [Marines] can play in the barracks,” said Capt. Matthew Tweedy, a company commander with 4th Marine Regiment. “It was never designed to replace going to the field or the training we have to do in the infantry, but it’s different than the same powerpoint that is used so frequently. The primary focus is to cultivate judgement and enhanced decision making at every level. There's always a winner and a loser; there’s no draws. It gives a sense of accomplishment or defeat to the two that are playing. You’re face to face in this, where you can't have that in the same sense digitally. The human factors are in play with this. “
While field training can’t be replaced by a board game, it still lends itself to have similarities with understanding of major concepts of tactical advantage over the enemy. Having both advantages and disadvantages with the terrain laid out on the map of the game, it helps the participating Marines keep the basic infantry fundamentals in mind while playing Memoir 44’.
“Its similar because you have to think about being several steps ahead of your opponent and having to plan out your main effort for the fight,” said Lance Cpl. Paul Delaney, an infantryman. “If I take a piece of terrain, it affects the future of your game. You could move wherever you want, but you have to keep in mind the options your enemy has while he’s trying to destroy you as well.”
Additionally, it’s scenarios are based on historical battles, so it offers a chance to have a class to learn what those who came before us had to go through. Noncommissioned officers have the ability to observe their junior Marines as well to assist in mentorship and improve the Marine’s concept of warfighting in a combat based scenario.
“Playing Memoir 44' essentially captures a point in history where everything you do comes down to your decision making process, ultimately giving you the upper hand when it comes down to you making contact with the enemy on the board,” said Sgt. Eddie Franco, an infantry squad leader. “Initially you are thrown right in a combat based scenario in which you have to start thinking about the enemies movement, the terrain, any obstacles, and adjacent units to be able to win the battle. I believe Memoir 44' does a great job initiating one’s decision making process by throwing your opponent right in front of you and giving you a task you are trying to accomplish every turn, which requires you to exploit every opportunity [you’re offered] to defeat your opponent. Having riflemen think critically and make decisions at an individual level to reach mission accomplishment or meet the commander's intent is ultimately what you want as a squad leader.”
The outcome of the game and how the Marines react to their opponent’s moves were observed by their commanding officers. With that, they are able to collect a series of characteristics about the individual Marines and provide mentorship.
“The goal of collecting analytics is to objectively assess whether or not you can pick out good decision makers with a board game,” said Capt. Ian Mckechnie, a company commander. “War games at the higher levels tend to be much more complicated, but using the board game Memoir 44’ is simple. The rules aren’t overly complicated so it lends itself to be easy to analyze. We can put together a small party of Marines to play the game and from a single round, we can collect how many times they attack compared to how many times they move. With that I can figure out if they’re overly aggressive or risk-averse.”
Many Marines see the dice and the cards and think the game is about luck and the cards they were dealt. After playing the game and seeing the warfighting concepts, they quickly learned it’s not really luck, but strategy. Being a successful strategist will make you stand out and have more victories, both in the boardgame and in a real-world scenario. Implementing wargaming has potential to be a great tool for increasing 3rd Marine Division’s lethality and the ability to fight tonight and win.
-
Memoir 44...ugh
-
<shakes head>
Not, I would have thought, the best gaming choice.
-
Memoir '44 is alright - as a VERY light and VERY un-tactical board game. WTF were they thinking?
-
They would have been better off with chess..............IMHO. :whistle:
-
Memoir is a small step up from something with Meeples.
-
Memoir '44 is alright - as a VERY light and VERY un-tactical board game. WTF were they thinking?
Is that you, Jason Cawley?! :waiting:
They were thinking that developing critical thinking skills aren't necessarily the same as tactical proficiency, and there are other reasons to play wargames than trying to prove who the best Patton in the unit is. :peace:
-
I guess it's alright for Marines :P
-
I dunno. I was in ROTC. I only played like a chump at being in the military. ;D
-
The Navy uses Battleship. Why shouldn't the Marines use Memoir '44? :whistle:
-
The Navy uses Battleship.
Worse. Harpoon.
-
RAND report on USMC wargaming centers
https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR2227.html (https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR2227.html)
-
Interesting stuff.
The U.S. Marine Corps has an opportunity not only to adopt wargaming best practices, tools, and approaches from other sources
There are a few games publishers that could do with reading that.