I've played Dishonored, though it was only for a total of about 6 hours. I'm not much into stealth games.
I also played Arcanum, though recently, via GOG. I didn't have the benefit of nostalgia to reflect back on, and the game was not bad, though it was unforgiving.
Bioshock: Infinite, I've played twice, and is a great game. It catches a LOT of flak for its racist overtones, but some fail to understand it's the portrayal of such themes in the city-in-the-clouds, not as some kind of racist message the developers were trying to expound. It's probably my favorite of the Bioshock series.