Sean Chick fan, Have all of his "hold the Line" games and some earlier versions like Clash for a Continent designed by Matt Burchfield, Grant Wylie, Mike Wylie. Bought all the original Horse and Musket series and recently purchased all the upgrade materials and a second copy of the original game to get a second map tile set and a second upgrade map. I am playing through all the scenarios from the first box and concurrently the IV edition scenarios. I have noticed some of the games are historical replays and are certainly lopsided with one side having little or no chance of winning. It's a great series with optional rules that enhance the game.