I stumbled upon this old forum post, and I still agree with your points about the Civ-series games. And the idea of barbarians capturing settlers/workers and forming new city-states is cool. Wonders allowed per city could also be improved. Actually, there's always some room for improvement. You know, this thread is probably the oldest one I've found about Civ games. Hope we'll manage to keep it updated.
Mod edit to remove spam links